Miss Congeniality – A HR Nightmare?

19 February 2022

An article in the latest issue of People Management Magazine casts a light on the HR and Employment law ramifications raised by plot elements of the hit film Miss Congeniality.

In the movie, agent Eric Matthews, in an attempt to identify which member of his team would be the best choice to go undercover at a beauty contest, uses his computer to simulate what his colleagues would look like in a bikini. When his coworkers gather at the computer to jeer at the results which include mock-ups of older women and senior leadership, we run into a problematic area.

They pose the question: Could this be classed as workplace bullying and discrimination? Could and should his employers have stopped this with proper training?

People Management spoke to Amo Bains, HR advisor at University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust.

“Jeering at what senior leadership and older female colleagues would look like in bikinis could potentially be classed as direct discrimination on the grounds of the protected characteristics of age and sex.”

Bains goes on to point out that, in lieu of a clearly defined policy on what constitutes bullying in the workplace, it is often characterised as “behaviour that is offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting and is often intended to humiliate or injure the recipient.”

The lesson to be learned is this: Employers should have a clear policy and procedure in place that outlines what constitutes bullying and discrimination in the workplace and how it will be dealt with. What is banter for one person crosses the line into bullying for another and everyone deserves to work in an environment where they are respected and valued for their knowledge and skills regardless of their age, sex, or other protected characteristic.

Follow us for the latest updates & news

Recent News

Northern Ireland exam board boss wins £100,000 settlement

Northern Ireland’s Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment (CCEA) has paid a substantial settlement to its former interim chief executive who complained of sex, race and age discrimination and constructive dismissal. The sum paid to Margaret Farragher,...

Catriona Crumlish v Health Service Executive – Court of Appeal

On Oct. 15th, The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court decision against Caitriona Crumlish in her claim against Letterkenny University hospital. The plaintiff alleged that there was a failure to detect and diagnose breast cancer in May 2017 resulting in an alleged...

Recent Articles

Psychological Injury

Nervous Shock I The law allows recovery of damages for so called nervous shock, within certain parameters and subject to limitations.  Nervous shock is the most commonly used legal label for psychiatric or psychological injury. Psychiatric injuries include...

Public Authorities and Negligence

Powers and Duties In broad terms, public authorities are subject to civil liability for negligence and other civil wrongs, in the same way as private individuals and companies.  The State and other public bodies are responsible for the actions and omissions of...

Duty of Care (Part 2)

Limits to Neighbour Principle The famous neighbour principle re-stated the general basis of liability in negligence. It stated, that “you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your...

Duty of Care (Part 1)

Meaning of Negligence I Negligence is used in a number of senses.  In one sense, it refers to a person’s state of mind.  An act is negligent, where it is done without giving due weight to the risks involved.  A person  (and his state of mind) may...

Join our Panel

You May Also Like...

Psychological Injury

Psychological Injury

Nervous Shock I The law allows recovery of damages for so called nervous shock, within certain parameters and subject...

Public Authorities and Negligence

Public Authorities and Negligence

Powers and Duties In broad terms, public authorities are subject to civil liability for negligence and other civil...

Duty of Care (Part 2)

Duty of Care (Part 2)

Limits to Neighbour Principle The famous neighbour principle re-stated the general basis of liability in negligence....